Summary
While exploring the expansive world ofBaldur’s Gate 3,players may stumble upon a mysterious book called The Necromancy of Thay. Reading this book successfully can provide characters with many benefits while failing is quite harmful.Baldur’s Gate 3players must choose to destroy the book, read it themselves, or give it to either Gale or Astarion. Each option comes with benefits and drawbacks due to the characters' differences.
All Necromancy Of Thay Choices and Benefits
Once players have found the Necromancy of Thay beneath the Blighted Village, they will have several options. To read the Necromancy of Thay, players must also collect the Dark Amethyst, obtained by defeating thePhase Spider Matriarchboss. The choices are:
Reading the Necromancy of Thay requires three Wisdom checks. There are drawbacks if the checks are failed.
1
CastSpeak with Deadwithout consuming spell slot
50-turn Disadvantage on WIS checks/saves
2
Disadvantage on WIS checks/saves until cleared with Remove Curse
3
Permanent +1 to Wisdom checks and saving throws
Same as Page 2
Some classes (Bard, Sorcerer, Warlock, and Wizard) can use alternate stats to make these checks. Later in the game, the character who has read the Necromancy of Thay can also unlock Danse Macabre, a spell that summons several Ghouls.
This is generally the recommended option. The player character will always be in the party, allowing players to get the most benefit from the new abilities. The Danse Macabre summon spell is particularly useful in several late-game quests, including the final battle against theNetherbrain inBG3. There is generally no drawback to choosing the player as the reader, except for a slight disapproval from Wyll and Karlach upon opening the book for the first time.
HavingBaldur’s Gate 3’s Galeconsume the Necromancy of Thay is generally not recommended. It removes the option to have anyone read the book and, while it does count as one of the magical items players need to feed Gale to keep him in the party, there are many cheaper and less valuable items found throughout Act 1 that work just as well.
Having Gale read the Necromancy of Thay is a good option. As a Wizard, he can make Intelligence checks instead of Wisdom, and his naturally high Intelligence makes him extremely likely to pass them with ease. His low Wisdom of 10 could definitely use the boost from reading the book fully. Gale can also pair the Danse Macabre with theWizard spells inBG3Conjure Elemental and Create Undead to easily overwhelm enemies.
On the surface, choosing Astarion seems like the worst option, as - unless reclassed - he will struggle with the checks due to his Wisdom of 13, and Wisdom is not often a key stat for rogues. However, should players makeAstarion the Vampire Ascendant, he becomes a perfect fit for the Necromancy’s benefits. His new Necrotic damage-dealing powers make him well-suited to classes like Monk that do use Wisdom, and he can set the uncontrollable Ghouls on enemies and then safely vanish using his new Misty Escape action.
